Untangling the Web of Copper Fungicides

Fire blight season is approaching, and delayed dormant applications of copper fungicides are commonly recommended for management of various tree fruit diseases.  But there are so many...

Below is a summary of copper formulations, their characteristics, and their limitations. 

Copper Fungicides

·       Fixed Copper

o   Safer for plant tissue than “bluestone” copper (see below)

o   May be used throughout growing season, but may cause fruit russetting

o   Low solubility in water, lower risk for phytotoxicity

o   Release copper ions slowly (with water/rain), longer residual

o   Slow drying time (rainy conditions) increases solubility, ion release, and phytotoxicity

o   Acidic conditions/additives increase solubility, ion release, and phytotoxicity

§  Adjuvants, phosphorus acid fungicides, and mancozeb lower pH

o   Use high rates during dormancy for fire blight management (until ½” green)

o   Lower rates during growing season for management of other diseases, may add lime

o   Common forms of fixed copper fungicides

§  Basic copper sulfate – Cuprofix, Basicop, Phyton, Agristar

§  Copper Hydroxide – Kocide, Champ, Badge, NuCop, CuPro

§  Copper oxychloride sulfate – C-O-C-S

§  Cuprous oxide – Nordox, ChemCopp

·       Copper sulfate pentahydrate – bluestone

o   Dormant spray, only

o   CuSO₄.5H₂O

o   Highly soluble ions, phytotoxic

o   Often combined with lime to help tie up copper ions

o   No residual activity, rapid release of copper ions

o   Common brands of copper sulfate

§  Mastercop, Magna Bon, Aquavet, Delcup

  

Tree fruit diseases managed with copper fungicides:

•                 Fire blight (spray guide recommendations: dormant – label: silver tip to green tip)
•                  Apple scab (dormant to pink)
•               Bacterial canker (after harvest and late dormant)
•                Bacterial spot (dormant/budswell, pink, and petal fall)
•                Peach leaf curl (dormant)
•                Cherry leaf spot (after petal fall)
•                Black knot (dormant)

Copper is an antimicrobial; it is not selective.  Kills any exposed plant cells, bacteria, and fungi

Large numbers of copper ions (rapid release of ions) are phytotoxic to plant tissue, especially leaf tissue

Copper fungicides are not systemic and wash off with rain.  Fixed coppers have more residual activity due to slow release of copper ions.

Metallic copper equivalent is the amount of copper available for fungicidal activity (different from active ingredient).  Basic copper sulfate usually contains the highest metallic copper equivalent.

Copper can accumulate in soils, inhibit plant growth, and is toxic to microorganisms and earthworms

More on fire blight at http://nicolewarduk.blogspot.com/2013/04/fire-blight-infections-occur-during.html

 

Fire Blight Season is Approaching – Preventative Copper is Recommended

As apple flowering-season approaches, growers should begin thinking about management of fire blight.  This bacterial disease can cause severe damage on apples, pears, and related ornamental plants during warm, rainy spring weather.

 

There is no single method that will provide consistent and reliable control. Management of fire blight requires an integrated approach that relies primarily on cultural practices and is supported by the judicious use of bactericides.



Fig 1 – Blossom blight phase of fire blight in which bacteria infect blossoms during bloom.

Disease Development: The fire blight bacterium overwinters primarily in cankered or diseased branches and trunks. During spring, bacteria-laden ooze is exuded from canker margins. Splashing rain and insects carry the pathogen to blossoms (Fig 1), and bees further spread the pathogen as they pollinate.

 

If weather is warm and rainy, populations of the causal bacterium (Erwinia amylovora) double every few hours, and more than a million bacterial cells can colonize a single floral stigma. Rain or dew then washes the bacteria into openings at the base of blossoms. Resulting symptoms are called blossom blight.  Infections can spread from blossoms to supporting spurs and branches, causing cankers that eventually kill entire branches (Fig 2).

 

Even if there is no blossom infection, shoot infections may occur. Bacterial cells infect externally through shoot tips, as young, succulent tissue is susceptible during periods of rapid growth. This phase of fire blight is called shoot blight or shepherd’s crook.  

 

Fig 2 – Flower and shoot infections can spread to branches, causing cankers that eventually kill entire limbs.  The fire blight bacterium overwinters in cankers and dead wood.

 

Bactericides:  During bud swell (late dormancy), an application of copper fungicide (e.g. Kocide or other fixed copper) should be applied, especially if fire blight was severe last year.  This copper application should reduce amounts of bacterium present on the surfaces of branches and spurs, reducing risk for disease development.  Do not apply copper after ¼ inch green leaf stage, as can be phytotoxic (cause foliar burn). 

 

During bloom, beginning at the first sign of open blossoms, a bactericide such as streptomycin (e.g. Agri-strep) should be applied at 4- to 5-day intervals through petal fall.  A minimum of two applications is recommended.  Another type of bactericide, oxytetracycline (e.g. Mycoshield) may be substituted, but it is not as effective as streptomycin.  Oxytetracycline may be mixed with streptomycin bactericides to help reduce the risk for resistance development.  Disease risk assessment sites (see below) may be used to improve timing and efficacy of bactericide applications.  Note:  Home orchards are usually not sprayed with antibiotics, so the preventative copper spray is critical.

 

After bloom, certain weather conditions can increase risk for shoot infections.  This shoot blight phase can be severe during rapid shoot development, especially under warm, rainy conditions.  The growth regulator prohexadione calcium (e.g. Apogee) reduces terminal growth, reducing succulent tissue that is most susceptible to infection.

 

Pruning: Growers should remove all damaged, dead, or diseased wood from trees during dormancy, before bacteria become active this spring.  This will help eliminate large amounts of infective inoculum.    

 

Disease Risk Assessment & Weather Models: Plant disease prediction models utilize weather data to analyze disease risk. The University of Kentucky maintains weather stations and incorporates this data into disease risk predictions models. Models can be found at http://wwwagwx.ca.uky.edu/plant_disease.html

  

More information:  See also our newest fact sheet Fire Blight http://www.ca.uky.edu/agcollege/plantpathology/ext_files/PPFShtml/PPFS-FR-T-12.pdf

Midwest Tree Fruit Spray Guide http://www.ca.uky.edu/agcollege/plantpathology/ext_files/PPFShtml/MW_tree_fruit_spray_guide_ID-92_(2013)[1].pdf

Disease and Insect Control Programs for Homegrown Fruit in Kentucky http://www.ca.uky.edu/agc/pubs/id/id21/id21.pdf